21.1: The Age of Enlightenment

21.1.1: Enlightenment Ideals

Learning Objective

Identify the core ideas that drove the Age of Enlightenment

Key Points

• The
  Age of Enlightenment was a philosophical
  movement that dominated the world of ideas in Europe in the 18th century.
  Centered on the idea that reason is the primary source of authority and
  legitimacy, this movement advocated such ideals as liberty, progress, tolerance,
  fraternity, constitutional government, and separation of church and state. 
• There
  is little consensus on the precise beginning of the Age of Enlightenment, but the beginning of the 18th century (1701) or the
  middle of the 17th century (1650) are commonly identified as starting points. French historians usually place the period
  between 1715 and 1789. Most scholars use the last years of the century, often choosing the
  French Revolution of 1789 or the beginning of the Napoleonic
  Wars (1804–15) to date the end of
  the Enlightenment.
• The
  Enlightenment took hold in most European countries, often with a specific local
  emphasis.
  The
  cultural exchange during the Age of Enlightenment ran between particular European countries and also in both directions across
  the Atlantic. 
• There were two distinct
  lines of Enlightenment thought. The radical Enlightenment advocated democracy, individual liberty, freedom of
  expression, and eradication of religious authority. A second, more moderate
  variety sought accommodation between reform and the traditional systems of
  power and faith. 
• Science
  came to play a leading role in Enlightenment discourse and thought. The Enlightenment has long been hailed as the foundation of modern Western
  political and intellectual culture. It brought political modernization to the
  West. In
  religion, Enlightenment era commentary was a response to the preceding century
  of religious conflict in Europe. 
• Historians
  of race, gender, and class note that Enlightenment ideals were not originally
  envisioned as universal in the today’s sense of the word. Although they did
  eventually inspire the struggles for rights of people of color, women, or the
  working masses, most Enlightenment thinkers did not advocate equality for all,
  regardless of race, gender, or class, but rather insisted that rights and
  freedoms were not hereditary.

Key Terms

reductionism

Several related but distinct philosophical positions regarding the connections between theories, “reducing” one idea to another, more basic one. In the sciences, its methodologies attempt to explain entire systems in terms of their individual, constituent parts and interactions.

scientific method

A body of techniques for investigating phenomena,
acquiring new knowledge, or correcting and integrating previous knowledge that
apply empirical or measurable evidence subject to specific principles
of reasoning. It has characterized natural science since the 17th
century, consisting of systematic observation, measurement, and experimentation, and
the formulation, testing, and modification of hypotheses.

cogito ergo sum

A Latin philosophical proposition by René Descartes usually translated into English as “I think, therefore I am.” The phrase originally appeared in his Discourse on the Method. This proposition became a fundamental element of Western philosophy, as it purported to form a secure foundation for knowledge in the face of radical doubt.
While other knowledge could be a figment of imagination, deception, or mistake, Descartes asserted that the very act of doubting one’s own existence served—at minimum—as proof of the reality of one’s own mind.

empiricism

The theory that knowledge comes primarily from
sensory experience. It emphasizes evidence, especially data gathered through experimentation and use of the scientific method.

The Age of Enlightenment

The Age of Enlightenment, also known as the Enlightenment, was a philosophical
movement that dominated the world of ideas in Europe in the 18th century. Centered on the idea that reason is the primary source of authority
and legitimacy, this movement advocated such ideals as liberty, progress, tolerance,
fraternity, constitutional government, and separation of church and state. The
Enlightenment was marked by an emphasis on the scientific method and
reductionism along with increased questioning of religious orthodoxy. The core ideas advocated by modern democracies, including the civil society, human and civil rights, and separation of powers, are the product of the Enlightenment. Furthermore, the sciences and academic disciplines (including social sciences and the humanities) as we know them today, based on empirical methods, are also rooted in the Age of Enlightenment. All these developments, which followed and partly overlapped with the European exploration and colonization of the Americas and the intensification of the European presence in Asia and Africa, make the Enlightenment a starting point of what some historians define as the European Moment in World History: the long period of often tragic European domination over the rest of the world. 

There is little consensus on the precise beginning of the Age of Enlightenment, with the beginning of the 18th century (1701) or the middle of the 17th century (1650) often considered starting points. French historians usually place the period between 1715 and 1789, from the beginning of the reign of Louis XV until the French Revolution. In the mid-17th century, the Enlightenment traces its origins to Descartes’ Discourse on Method, published in 1637. In France, many cite the publication of Isaac Newton’s Principia Mathematica in 1687. Some historians and philosophers have argued that the beginning of the Enlightenment is when Descartes shifted the epistemological basis from external authority to internal certainty by his cogito ergo sum (1637). 

As to its end, most scholars use the last years of the century, often choosing the French Revolution of 1789 or the beginning of the Napoleonic Wars (1804–15) to date the end of the Enlightenment.

National Varieties

The Enlightenment took hold in most European countries, often with a specific local emphasis. For example, in France it became associated with anti-government and anti-Church radicalism, while in Germany it reached deep into the middle classes and took a spiritualistic and nationalistic tone without threatening governments or established churches. Government responses varied widely. In France, the government was hostile and Enlightenment thinkers fought against its censorship, sometimes being imprisoned or hounded into exile. The British government largely ignored the Enlightenment’s leaders in England and Scotland. The Scottish Enlightenment, with its mostly liberal Calvinist and Newtonian focus, played a major role in the further development of the transatlantic Enlightenment. In Italy, the significant reduction in the Church’s power led to a period of great thought and invention, including scientific discoveries. In Russia, the government began to actively encourage the proliferation of arts and sciences in the mid-18th century. This era produced the first Russian university, library, theater, public museum, and independent press. Several Americans, especially Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson, played a major role in bringing Enlightenment ideas to the New World and in influencing British and French thinkers. The cultural exchange during the Age of Enlightenment ran in both directions across the Atlantic. In their development of the ideas of natural freedom, Europeans and American thinkers drew from American Indian cultural practices and beliefs. 

Major Enlightenment Ideas

In
the mid-18th century, Europe witnessed an explosion of philosophic and
scientific activity that challenged traditional doctrines and dogmas. The
philosophic movement was led by Voltaire and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who argued
for a society based upon reason rather than faith and Catholic doctrine, for a
new civil order based on natural law, and for science based on experiments and
observation. The political philosopher Montesquieu introduced the idea of a
separation of powers in a government, a concept which was enthusiastically
adopted by the authors of the United States Constitution. 

There
were two distinct lines of Enlightenment thought. The radical enlightenment,
inspired by the philosophy of Spinoza, advocated democracy, individual
liberty, freedom of expression, and eradication of religious authority. A second,
more moderate variety, supported by René Descartes, John Locke, Christian
Wolff, Isaac Newton and others, sought accommodation between reform and the
traditional systems of power and faith. 

Science came to play a leading role in Enlightenment discourse and
thought. Many Enlightenment writers and thinkers had backgrounds in the
sciences and associated scientific advancement with the overthrow of religion
and traditional authority in favor of the development of free speech and
thought. Broadly speaking, Enlightenment science greatly valued empiricism and
rational thought and was embedded with the Enlightenment ideal of advancement
and progress. However, as with most Enlightenment views, the benefits of science were
not seen universally.

The
Enlightenment has also long been hailed as the foundation of modern Western
political and intellectual culture. It brought political modernization to the
West in terms of focusing on democratic values and institutions and the
creation of modern, liberal democracies. The fundamentals of European liberal thought, including the
right of the individual, the natural equality of all men, the separation of powers, the artificial
character of the political order (which led to the later distinction between
civil society and the state), the view that all legitimate political power must
be “representative” and based on the consent of the people, and liberal interpretation of law that leaves people free to do whatever is not explicitly forbidden, were all developed by Enlightenment thinkers.

In religion, Enlightenment-era commentary was a response to the preceding century of religious
conflict in Europe. Enlightenment thinkers sought to curtail the political
power of organized religion and thereby prevent another age of intolerant
religious war. A number of novel ideas developed, including deism (belief in
God the Creator, with no reference to the Bible or any other source) and
atheism. The latter was much discussed but had few proponents. Many,
like Voltaire, held that without belief in a God who punishes evil, the moral
order of society was undermined.

Impact

The
ideas of the Enlightenment played a major role in inspiring the French
Revolution, which began in 1789 and emphasized the rights of common men as
opposed to the exclusive rights of the elites. As such, they laid the foundation for modern, rational, democratic societies. However, historians of race,
gender, and class note that Enlightenment ideals were not originally envisioned
as universal in the today’s sense of the word. Although they did eventually
inspire the struggles for rights of people of color, women, or the working
masses, most Enlightenment thinkers did not advocate equality for all, regardless of
race, gender, or class, but rather insisted that rights and freedoms were not
hereditary (the heredity of power and rights was a common pre-Enlightenment assumption). This perspective directly attacked the traditionally exclusive
position of the European aristocracy but was still largely focused on expanding
the rights of white males of a particular social standing. 

 

21.1.2: Scientific Exploration

Learning Objective

Describe advancements made in science and social sciences during the 18th century

Key Points

• Science came to play a leading role in Enlightenment discourse and ideas. The movement greatly valued empiricism and rational thought
  and was embedded with the Enlightenment ideal of advancement and progress.
  Similar rules were applied to social sciences. 

• Building on the body of work forwarded by Copernicus, Kepler and
  Newton, 18th-century astronomers refined telescopes, produced star catalogs,
  and worked towards explaining the motions of heavenly bodies and the
  consequences of universal gravitation. In 1781, amateur astronomer William
  Herschel was responsible for arguably the most important discovery in
  18th-century astronomy: a new planet later named Uranus.

• The 18th century witnessed the early modern reformulation of
  chemistry that culminated in the law of conservation of mass and the
  oxygen theory of combustion. 

• David Hume and other Scottish Enlightenment thinkers developed a “science of man.” Against philosophical rationalists, Hume held that passion
  rather than reason governs human behavior and argued against the existence of
  innate ideas, positing that all human knowledge is ultimately founded solely in
  experience. Modern sociology largely originated from these ideas.

• Adam Smith published The Wealth of Nations, often
  considered the first work on modern economics, in 1776. It had an immediate
  impact on British economic policy that continues into the 21st century.
  Enlightenment-era changes in law also continue to shape legal systems today.

• The Age of Enlightenment was also when the first scientific and
  literary journals were established. As a source of knowledge derived from
  science and reason, these journals were an implicit critique of existing notions
  of universal truth monopolized by monarchies, parliaments, and religious
  authorities.

Key Terms

chemical revolution

The 18th-century reformulation of chemistry that culminated in the law of conservation of mass and the oxygen theory of combustion. During the 19th and 20th century, this transformation was credited to the work of the French chemist Antoine Lavoisier (the “father of modern chemistry”). However, recent research notes that gradual changes in chemical theory and practice emerged over two centuries.

science of man

A topic in David Hume’s 18th century experimental philosophy A Treatise of Human Nature (1739). It expanded the understanding of facets of human nature, including senses, impressions, ideas, imagination, passions, morality, justice, and society.

empiricism

The theory that
knowledge comes primarily from sensory experience. It emphasizes
evidence gathered through
experimentation and by use of the scientific method.

While
the Enlightenment cannot be pigeonholed into a specific doctrine or set of
dogmas, science is a key part of the ideals of this movement. Many Enlightenment writers and thinkers had backgrounds in the
sciences and associated scientific advancement with the overthrow of religion
and traditional authority in favor of the development of free speech and
thought. Broadly speaking, Enlightenment science greatly valued empiricism and
rational thought, embedded with the ideals of advancement
and progress. Similar rules were applied to social sciences. 

Astronomy

Building on the body of work forwarded by Copernicus, Kepler and Newton, 18th-century astronomers refined telescopes, produced star catalogs, and worked towards explaining the motions of heavenly bodies and the consequences of universal gravitation. In 1705, astronomer Edward Halley correctly linked historical descriptions of particularly bright comets to the reappearance of just one (later named Halley’s Comet), based on his computation of the orbits of comets. James Bradley realized that the unexplained motion of stars he had early observed with Samuel Molyneux was caused by the aberration of light. He also came fairly close to the estimation of the speed of light. Observations of Venus in the 18th century became an important step in describing atmospheres, including the work of Mikhail Lomonosov, Johann Hieronymus Schröter, and Alexis Claude de Clairaut. In 1781, amateur astronomer William Herschel was responsible for arguably the most important discovery in 18th-century astronomy. He spotted a new planet that he named Georgium Sidus. The name Uranus, proposed by Johann Bode, came into widespread usage after Herschel’s death. On the theoretical side of astronomy, the English natural philosopher John Michell first proposed the existence of dark stars in 1783. 

Chemistry

The 18th century witnessed the early modern reformulation of chemistry that culminated in the law of conservation of mass and the oxygen theory of combustion. This period was eventually called the chemical revolution. According to an earlier theory, a substance called phlogiston was released from inflammable materials through burning. The resulting product was termed calx, which was considered a dephlogisticated substance in its true form. The first strong evidence against phlogiston theory came from Joseph Black, Joseph Priestley, and Henry Cavendish, who all identified different gases that composed air. However, it was not until Antoine Lavoisier discovered in 1772 that sulphur and phosphorus grew heavier when burned that the phlogiston theory began to unravel. Lavoisier subsequently discovered and named oxygen, as well as described its roles in animal respiration and the calcination of metals exposed to air (1774–1778). In 1783, he found that water was a compound of oxygen and hydrogen. Transition to and acceptance of Lavoisier’s findings varied in pace across Europe. Eventually, however, the oxygen-based theory of combustion drowned out the phlogiston theory and in the process created the basis of modern chemistry.

Social Sciences

David Hume and other Scottish Enlightenment thinkers developed a “science of man” that was expressed historically in works by authors including James Burnett, Adam Ferguson, John Millar, and William Robertson, all of whom merged a scientific study of how humans behaved in prehistoric and ancient cultures with a strong awareness of the determining forces of modernity. Against philosophical rationalists, Hume held that passion rather than reason governs human behavior and argued against the existence of innate ideas, positing that all human knowledge is ultimately founded solely in experience. According to Hume, genuine knowledge must either be directly traceable to objects perceived in experience or result from abstract reasoning about relations between ideas derived from experience.
Modern sociology largely originated from the science of ma’ movement.

Adam Smith published The Wealth of Nations, often considered the first work on modern economics, in 1776. It had an immediate impact on British economic policy that continues into the 21st century. The book was immediately preceded and influenced by Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot and Baron de Laune drafts of Reflections on the Formation and Distribution of Wealth (Paris, 1766). Smith acknowledged indebtedness to this work and may have been its original English translator.

Enlightenment-era changes in law also continue to shape legal systems today. Cesare Beccaria, a jurist and one of the great Enlightenment writers, published his masterpiece Of Crimes and Punishments in 1764. Beccaria is recognized as one of the fathers of classical criminal theory. His treatise condemned torture and the death penalty and was a founding work in the field of penology (the study of the punishment of crime and prison management). It also promoted criminal justice.

Another prominent intellectual was Francesco Mario Pagano, whose work Saggi Politici (Political Essays, 1783)
argued against torture and capital punishment and advocated more benign penal codes.

Scientific Publications

The Age of Enlightenment was also when the first scientific and literary journals were established. The first journal, the Parisian Journal des Sçavans, appeared in 1665. However, it was not until 1682 that periodicals began to be more widely produced. French and Latin were the dominant languages of publication, but there was also a steady demand for material in German and Dutch. There was generally low demand for English publications on the Continent, which was echoed by England’s similar lack of desire for French works. Languages commanding less of an international market such as Danish, Spanish, and Portuguese found journal success more difficult and often used an international language instead. French slowly took over Latin’s status as the lingua franca of learned circles. This in turn gave precedence to the publishing industry in Holland, where the vast majority of these French language periodicals were produced. As a source of knowledge derived from science and reason, the journals were an implicit critique of existing notions of universal truth monopolized by monarchies, parliaments, and religious authorities. 

21.1.3: The Popularization of Science

Learning Objective

Describe advancements made in the popularization of science during the 18th century

Key Points

• Science during the Enlightenment was dominated
  by scientific societies and academies, which largely replaced universities
  as centers of scientific research and development. Scientific academies and
  societies grew out of the Scientific Revolution as the creators of scientific
  knowledge in contrast to the scholasticism of the university. 
• National scientific societies were founded
  throughout the Enlightenment era in the urban hotbeds of scientific development
  across Europe. Many regional and provincial
  societies followed along with some smaller private counterparts. Activities included research, experimentation, sponsoring
  essay contests, and collaborative projects between societies. 
• Academies and societies disseminated Enlightenment science by publishing the works of their members. The publication schedules were typically irregular, with periods between volumes sometimes lasting years. While the journals of the academies primarily published scientific
  papers, the independent periodicals that followed were a mix of reviews, abstracts, translations
  of foreign texts, and sometimes derivative, reprinted materials. 
• Although dictionaries and
  encyclopedias have existed since ancient times, during the Enlightenment they evolved from a simple list of definitions to far more detailed discussions of those words. The most well-known of the 18th century encyclopedic dictionaries is Encyclopaedia, or a Systematic Dictionary of
  the Sciences, Arts, and Crafts.
• During the Enlightenment, science began to appeal to an increasingly larger audience. A more literate population seeking
  knowledge and education in both the arts and the sciences drove the expansion
  of print culture and the dissemination of scientific learning in coffeehouses, at public lectures, and through popular publications.
• During
  the Enlightenment era, women were excluded from scientific societies,
  universities, and learned professions. Despite
  these limitations, many women made valuable contributions to science during the
  18th century.

Key Terms

Encyclopaedia, or a Systematic Dictionary of the Sciences, Arts, and Crafts

A general encyclopedia published in France between 1751 and 1772, with later supplements, revised editions, and translations. It had many writers, known as the Encyclopédistes, and was edited by Denis Diderot and until 1759 co-edited by Jean le Rond d’Alembert. It is most famous for representing the thought of the Enlightenment.

Scientific Revolution

The emergence of modern science during the early modern period, when developments in mathematics, physics, astronomy, biology (including human anatomy) and chemistry transformed society’s views about nature. It began in Europe towards the end of the Renaissance period and continued through the late 18th century, influencing the intellectual social movement known as the Enlightenment. While its dates are disputed, the publication of Nicolaus Copernicus’s De revolutionibus orbium coelestium (On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres) in 1543 is often cited as its beginning.

Conversations on the Plurality of Worlds

A popular science book by French author Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle published in 1686. It offered an explanation of the heliocentric model of the Universe, suggested by Nicolaus Copernicus in his 1543 work De revolutionibus orbium coelestium. The book, written in French and not in Latin as most scientific works of the era, was one of the first attempts to explain scientific theories in a popular language understandable to the wide audience.  

Societies and Academies

Science during the Enlightenment was dominated by scientific societies and academies, which largely replaced universities as centers of scientific research and development.
These organizations grew out of the Scientific Revolution as the creators of scientific knowledge in contrast to the scholasticism of the university. During the Enlightenment, some societies created or retained links to universities. However, contemporary sources distinguished universities from scientific societies by claiming that the university’s utility was in the transmission of knowledge, while societies functioned to create knowledge. As the role of universities in institutionalized science began to diminish, learned societies became the cornerstone of organized science. After 1700, many official academies and societies were founded in Europe, with more than seventy official scientific societies in existence by 1789. In reference to this growth, Bernard de Fontenelle coined the term “the Age of Academies” to describe the 18th century.

National scientific societies were founded in the urban hotbeds of scientific development across Europe. In the 17th century, the Royal Society of London (1662), the Paris Académie Royale des Sciences (1666), and the Berlin Akademie der Wissenschaften (1700) came into existence. In the first half of the 18th century, the Academia Scientiarum Imperialis (1724) in St. Petersburg, and the Kungliga Vetenskapsakademien (Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences) (1739) were created. Many regional and provincial societies followed along with some smaller private counterparts. Official scientific societies were chartered by the state to provide technical expertise, which resulted in direct, close contact between the scientific community and government bodies. State sponsorship was beneficial to the societies as it brought finance and recognition along with a measure of freedom in management. Most societies were granted permission to oversee their own publications, control the election of new members, and otherwise provide administration. Membership in academies and societies was highly selective. Activities included research, experimentation, sponsoring essay contests, and collaborative projects between societies. 

Scientific and Popular Publications

Academies and societies served to disseminate Enlightenment science by publishing the scientific works of their members as well as their proceedings. With the exception of the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society by the Royal Society of London, which was published on a regular, quarterly basis, publication schedules were typically irregular, with periods between volumes sometimes lasting years. These and other limitations of academic journals left considerable space for the rise of independent periodicals, which excited scientific interest in the general public. While the journals of the academies primarily published scientific papers, independent periodicals were a mix of reviews, abstracts, translations of foreign texts, and sometimes derivative, reprinted materials. Most of these texts were published in the local vernacular, so their continental spread depended on the language of the readers. For example, in 1761, Russian scientist Mikhail Lomonosov correctly attributed the ring of light around Venus, visible during the planet’s transit, as the planet’s atmosphere. However, because few scientists understood Russian outside of Russia, his discovery was not widely credited until 1910. With a wider audience and ever-increasing publication material, specialized journals emerged, reflecting the growing division between scientific disciplines in the Enlightenment era. 

Although dictionaries and encyclopedias have existed since ancient times, they evolved from simply a long list of definitions to detailed discussions of those words in 18th-century encyclopedic dictionaries. The works were part of an Enlightenment movement to systematize knowledge and provide education to a wider audience than the educated elite. As the 18th century progressed, the content of encyclopedias also changed according to readers’ tastes. Volumes tended to focus more strongly on secular affairs, particularly science and technology, rather than on matters of theology. The most well-known of these works is Denis Diderot and Jean le Rond d’Alembert’s
Encyclopaedia, or a Systematic Dictionary of the Sciences, Arts, and Crafts. The work, which began publication in 1751, was composed of thirty-five volumes and more than 71,000 separate entries. Many entries describe the sciences and crafts in detail. The massive work was arranged according to a “tree of knowledge.” The tree reflected the marked division between the arts and sciences, largely a result of the rise of empiricism. Both areas of knowledge were united by philosophy, the trunk of the tree of knowledge. 

Science and the Public

During Enlightenment, the discipline of science began to appeal to a consistently growing audience. An increasingly literate population seeking knowledge and education in both the arts and the sciences drove the expansion of print culture and the dissemination of scientific learning.
The British coffeehouse is an early example of this phenomenon, as their establishment created a new public forum for political, philosophical, and scientific discourse. In the mid-16th century, coffeehouses cropped up around Oxford, where the academic community began to capitalize on the unregulated conversation the coffeehouse allowed. The new social space was used by some scholars as a place to discuss science and experiments outside the laboratory of the official institution. Education was a central theme, and some patrons began offering lessons to others. As coffeehouses developed in London, customers heard lectures on scientific subjects such as astronomy and mathematics for an exceedingly low price.

Public lecture courses offered scientists unaffiliated with official organizations a forum to transmit scientific knowledge and their own ideas, leading to the opportunity to carve out a reputation and even make a living. The public, on the other hand, gained both knowledge and entertainment from demonstration lectures. Courses varied in duration from one to four weeks to a few months or even the entire academic year and were offered at virtually any time of day. The importance of the lectures was not in teaching complex scientific subjects, but rather in demonstrating the principles of scientific disciplines and encouraging discussion and debate.

Barred from the universities and other institutions, women were often in attendance at demonstration lectures and constituted a significant number of auditors.  

Increasing literacy rates in Europe during the Enlightenment enabled science to enter popular culture through print. More formal works included explanations of scientific theories for individuals lacking the educational background to comprehend the original scientific text. The publication of Bernard de Fontenelle’s Conversations on the Plurality of Worlds (1686) marked the first significant work that expressed scientific theory and knowledge expressly for the laity, in the vernacular and with the entertainment of readers in mind. The book specifically addressed women with an interest in scientific writing and inspired a variety of similar works written in a discursive style. These were more accessible to the reader than complicated articles, treatises, and books published by the academies and scientists. 

Science and Gender

During the Enlightenment, women were excluded from scientific societies, universities, and learned professions. They were educated, if at all, through self-study, tutors, and by the teachings of more open-minded family members and relatives. With the exception of daughters of craftsmen, who sometimes learned their fathers’ professions by assisting in the workshop, learned women were primarily part of elite society. In addition, women’s inability to access scientific instruments (e.g., microscope) made it difficult for them to conduct independent research.  

Despite these limitations, many women made valuable contributions to science during the 18th century. Two notable women who managed to participate in formal institutions were Laura Bassi and the Russian Princess Yekaterina Dashkova. Bassi was an Italian physicist who received a PhD from the University of Bologna and began teaching there in 1732. Dashkova became the director of the Russian Imperial Academy of Sciences of St. Petersburg in 1783. Her personal relationship with Empress Catherine the Great allowed her to obtain the position, which marked in history the first appointment of a woman to the directorship of a scientific academy. More commonly, however, women participated in the sciences as collaborators of their male relative or spouse.
Others became illustrators or translators of scientific texts.

   

21.1.4: Enlightened Despotism

Learning Objective

Define enlightened despotism and provide examples

Key Points

• Enlightened despots held that royal power
  emanated not from divine right but from a social contract whereby a despot was
  entrusted with the power to govern in lieu of any other
  governments. In effect, the monarchs of enlightened absolutism strengthened
  their authority by improving the lives of their subjects. 
• An essay defending the system of enlightened despotism was penned by Frederick the Great, who ruled Prussia from 1740 to 1786. Frederick modernized
  the Prussian bureaucracy and civil service and pursued religious policies
  throughout his realm that ranged from tolerance to segregation. Following the common interest among enlightened despots,
  he supported arts, philosophers that he favored, and complete freedom of
  the press and literature.
• Catherine II of Russia continued to modernize Russia along
  Western European lines, but her enlightened despotism manifested itself mostly
  with her commitment to arts, sciences, and the modernization of Russian
  education. While she introduced some administrative and economic reforms, military conscription and economy
  continued to depend on serfdom.
• Maria Theresa implemented
  significant reforms to strengthen Austria’s military and bureaucratic
  efficiency. She improved the economy of the state, introduced a national education system, and contributed to important reforms in medicine. However, unlike other enlightened despots, Maria Theresa found it hard to
  fit into the intellectual sphere of the Enlightenment and did not share fascination with Enlightenment ideals. 
• Joseph
  was a proponent of enlightened despotism but his commitment to modernizing
  reforms subsequently engendered significant opposition, which eventually
  culminated in a failure to fully implement his programs. Among other accomplishments, he inspired a complete reform of the legal system, ended censorship of the press and
  theater, and continued his mother’s reforms in education and medicine. 

Key Terms

serfdom

The status of many peasants under feudalism, specifically relating to manorialism. It was a condition of bondage that developed primarily during the High Middle Ages in Europe and lasted in some countries until the mid-19th century.

enlightened despotism

Also known as enlightened absolutism or benevolent absolutism, a form of absolute monarchy or despotism inspired by the Enlightenment. The monarchs who embraced it followed the participles of rationality. Some of them fostered education and allowed religious tolerance, freedom of speech, and the right to hold private property.
They held that royal power emanated not from divine right but from a social contract whereby a despot was entrusted with the power to govern in lieu of any other governments.

Encyclopédie

A general encyclopedia
published in France between 1751 and 1772, with later supplements, revised
editions, and translations. It had many writers, known as the Encyclopédistes.

It is most famous for representing the thought of the Enlightenment.

Enlightened Despotism

Major thinkers of the Age of Enlightenment are credited for the development of government theories critical to the creation and evolution of the modern civil-society-driven democratic state. Enlightened despotism, also called enlightened absolutism, was among the first ideas resulting from the political ideals of the Enlightenment.
The concept was formally described by the German historian Wilhelm Roscher in 1847 and remains controversial among scholars.

 

Enlightened despots held that royal power emanated not from divine right but from a social contract whereby a despot was entrusted with the power to govern in lieu of any other governments. In effect, the monarchs of enlightened absolutism strengthened their authority by improving the lives of their subjects. This philosophy implied that the sovereign knew the interests of his or her subjects better than they themselves did. The monarch taking responsibility for the subjects precluded their political participation. The difference between a despot and an enlightened despot is based on a broad analysis of the degree to which they embraced the Age of Enlightenment. However, historians debate the actual implementation of enlightened despotism. They distinguish between the “enlightenment” of the ruler personally versus that of his or her regime. 

Frederick the Great

Enlightened despotism was defended in an essay by Frederick the Great, who ruled Prussia from 1740 to 1786.
He was an enthusiast of French ideas and invited the prominent French Enlightenment philosopher Voltaire to live at his palace.
With the help of French experts, Frederick organized a system of indirect taxation, which provided the state with more revenue than direct taxation.
One of Frederick’s greatest achievements included the control of grain prices, whereby government storehouses would enable the civilian population to survive in needy regions, where the harvest was poor. Frederick modernized the Prussian bureaucracy and civil service and pursued religious policies throughout his realm that ranged from tolerance to segregation. 
He was largely non-practicing and tolerated all faiths in his realm, although Protestantism became the favored religion and Catholics were not chosen for higher state positions. While he protected and encouraged trade by Jewish citizens of the Empire, he repeatedly expressed strong anti-Semitic sentiments. He also encouraged immigrants of various nationalities and faiths to come to Prussia. Some critics, however, point out his oppressive measures against conquered Polish subjects after some Polish land fell under the control of the Prussian Empire. Following the common interest among enlightened despots, Frederick supported arts, philosophers that he favored, and complete freedom of the press and literature.

Catherine the Great

Catherine II of Russia was the most renowned and the longest-ruling female leader of Russia, reigning from 1762 until her death in 1796. An admirer of Peter the Great, she continued to modernize Russia along Western European lines but her enlightened despotism manifested itself mostly with her commitment to arts, sciences, and the modernization of Russian education. The Hermitage Museum, which now occupies the whole Winter Palace, began as Catherine’s personal collection. She wrote comedies, fiction, and memoirs, while cultivating Voltaire, Diderot, and d’Alembert—all French encyclopedists who later cemented her reputation in their writings. The leading European economists of her day became foreign members of the Free Economic Society, established on her suggestion in Saint Petersburg in 1765. She also recruited Western European scientists. Within a few months of her accession in 1762, having heard the French government threatened to stop the publication of the famous French Encyclopédie on account of its irreligious spirit, Catherine proposed to Diderot that he should complete his great work in Russia under her protection. She believed a ‘new kind of person’ could be created by instilling Russian children with Western European education. She continued to investigate educational theory and practice of other countries and while she introduced some educational reforms, she failed to establish a national school system.

Although Catherine refrained from putting most democratic principles into practice, she issued codes addressing some modernization trends, including dividing the country into provinces and districts, limiting the power of nobles, creating a middle estate, and a number of economic reforms. However, military conscription and economy continued to depend on serfdom, and the increasing demands of the state and private landowners led to increased levels of reliance on serfs. 

Maria Theresa

Maria Theresa was the only female ruler of the Habsburg dominions and the last of the House of Habsburg.

She implemented significant reforms to strengthen Austria’s military and bureaucratic efficiency. She doubled the state revenue between 1754 and 1764, though her attempt to tax clergy and nobility was only partially successful. Nevertheless, her financial reforms greatly improved the economy. In 1760, Maria Theresa created the council of state, which served as a committee of expert advisors. It lacked executive or legislative authority but nevertheless showed the difference between the autocratic form of government. In medicine, her decision to have her children inoculated after the smallpox epidemic of 1767 was responsible for changing Austrian physicians’ negative view of vaccination. Austria outlawed witch burning and torture in 1776. It was later reintroduced, but the progressive nature of these reforms remains noted. Education was one of the most notable reforms of Maria Theresa’s rule. In a new school system based on that of Prussia, all children of both genders from the ages were required to attend school from the ages of 6 to 12, although the law turned out to be very difficult to execute. 

However, Maria Theresa  found it hard to fit into the intellectual sphere of the Enlightenment. For example, she believed that religious unity was necessary for a peaceful public life and explicitly rejected the idea of religious tolerance.
She regarded both the Jews and Protestants as dangerous to the state and actively tried to suppress them. As a young monarch who fought two dynastic wars, she believed that her cause should be the cause of her subjects, but in her later years she would believe that their cause must be hers.

Joseph II of Austria

Maria Theresa’s oldest son, Joseph II, Holy Roman Emperor from 1765 to 1790 and ruler of the Habsburg lands from 1780 to 1790, was at ease with Enlightenment ideas.  Joseph was a proponent of enlightened despotism, but his commitment to modernizing reforms engendered significant opposition, which eventually culminated in a failure to fully implement his programs. 

Joseph inspired a complete reform of the legal system, abolished brutal punishments and the death penalty in most instances, and imposed the principle of complete equality of treatment for all offenders. He ended censorship of the press and theater. In 1781–82, he extended full legal freedom to serfs. The landlords, however, found their economic position threatened and eventually reversed the policy. To equalize the incidence of taxation, Joseph ordered an appraisal of all the lands of the empire to impose a single egalitarian tax on land.  However, most of his financial reforms were repealed shortly before or after Joseph’s death in 1790.

To produce a literate citizenry, elementary education was made compulsory for all boys and girls and higher education on practical lines was offered for a select few. Joseph created scholarships for talented poor students and allowed the establishment of schools for Jews and other religious minorities. In 1784, he ordered that the country change its language of instruction from Latin to German, a highly controversial step in a multilingual empire. Joseph also attempted to centralize medical care in Vienna through the construction of a single, large hospital, the famous Allgemeines Krankenhaus, which opened in 1784. Centralization, however, worsened sanitation problems, causing epidemics and a 20% death rate in the new hospital, but the city became preeminent in the medical field in the next century.

Probably the most unpopular of all his reforms was his attempted modernization of the highly traditional Catholic Church. Calling himself the guardian of Catholicism, Joseph II struck vigorously at papal power. He tried to make the Catholic Church in his empire the tool of the state, independent of Rome.
Joseph was very friendly to Freemasonry, as he found it highly compatible with his own Enlightenment philosophy, although he apparently never joined the Lodge himself. In 1789, he issued a charter of religious toleration for the Jews of Galicia, a region with a large Yiddish-speaking traditional Jewish population. The charter abolished communal autonomy whereby the Jews controlled their internal affairs. It promoted Germanization and the wearing of non-Jewish clothing.