Ethical Decision Making
Ethical decision making is the process of assessing the moral implications of a course of action.
Identify the elements of decision making that are directly affected by ethical considerations and social expectations
- All business decisions have an ethical or moral dimension because they have an effect on stakeholders.
- Ethical decisions cannot be made solely through objective analysis or consideration of data and information, but must rely on judgment and interpretation.
- Making ethical decisions also involves choice about who should be involved in the process and how the decision should be made.
- cognitive: Of the mental functions that deal with logic, as opposed to affective functions, which deal with emotion.
- ethics: The study of principles relating to right and wrong conduct.
- decision: A choice or judgement.
Ethics are moral principles that guide a person’s behavior. These morals are shaped by social norms, cultural practices, and religious influences. Ethical decision making is the process of assessing the moral implications of a course of action. All decisions have an ethical or moral dimension for a simple reason—they have an effect on others. Managers and leaders need to be aware of their own ethical and moral beliefs so they can draw on them when they face difficult decisions.
Ethical decisions can involve several determinations. The field of ethics, also known as moral philosophy, shows that there are various ways of systematizing, defending, and recommending concepts of right and wrong conduct. For example, from a consequentialist standpoint, a morally right action is one that produces a good outcome, or consequence. A utilitarian perspective takes the position that the proper course of action is one that maximizes overall happiness.
Most ethical decisions exist in a gray area where there is no clear-cut or obvious decision that can be determined solely through quantitative analysis or consideration of objective data or information. Ethical decision making requires judgment and interpretation, the application of a set of values to a set of perceptions and estimates of the consequences of an action. Sometimes ethical decisions involve choosing not between good and bad, but between good and better or between bad and worse.
Making ethical decisions also involves choice about who should be involved in the process and how the decision should be made. For example, if a decision will have a significant impact on the local community, leaders may feel obligated to invite a representative of the community to participate in discussions. Similarly, decisions with a significant ethical dimension may benefit from being made by consensus rather than by fiat—to demonstrate that the choice is consistent with an organization ‘s espoused values.
Training Ethical Decision Making
Organizations use compliance and ethics programs to demonstrate and reinforce their commitment to ethical practices.
Recognize the value in ensuring that managers are trained in business ethics and legal standards, particularly in light of the growing complexity of legal factors
- Organizations use compliance and ethics programs to clarify and communicate their ethical standards to employees and help develop their ethical decision -making skills.
- A compliance and ethics program can identify the boundaries of legal and ethical behavior and establish a system to alert management when the organization is getting close to (or crossing) a boundary or approaching an obstacle that prevents the achievement of a business objective.
- Ethics training inside corporations is aimed at helping employees address the moral dimension of business decisions.
- ethics: The study of principles relating to right and wrong conduct.
- governance: The implementation of policies, processes, and rights.
Many organizations implement compliance and ethics programs to help guide the decision making and behavior of employees. Compliance with regulatory requirements and the organization’s own policies are a critical component of effective risk management. Monitoring and maintaining compliance is not just to keep the regulators happy—it is one of the most important ways for an organization to maintain its ethical health, support its long-term prosperity, and preserve and promote its values.
On a more practical level, a compliance and ethics program supports the organization’s business objectives, identifies the boundaries of legal and ethical behavior, and establishes a system to alert management when the organization is getting close to (or crossing) a legal or ethical boundary. Once an issue is detected, management must be prepared to respond quickly and appropriately to minimize the impact on the organization. The presence of compliance and ethics programs demonstrates an organization’s commitment to creating a work environment and corporate culture that values doing what is right, good, and just.
Ethics training inside corporations is aimed at helping employees address the moral dimension of business decisions. Training for ethical decision making can include workshops, guest lectures, and manager/employee discussions. Most ethics training focuses on clarifying and communicating an organization’s ethical code so employees understand what is expected. Some learning opportunities go beyond this to focus on how to take action when ethics are involved in a decision. Discussions of scenarios and role-playing exercises simulate real decision-making situations and provide practice in how to think through ethical considerations. Some ethics training will also cover the resources available to help employees when they face an ethical dilemma or suspect that someone in the organization has made an ethical breach.
Whistle-blower protection provides safeguards against retaliation for those who report suspected legal or ethical violations.
Outline the methods with which the U.S. government seeks to protect whistle-blowers to maintain an equitable workplace
- A whistle-blower is a person who tells the public or someone in authority about alleged misconduct occurring in a government department, private company, or organization.
- Many organizations establish internal processes through which employees can come forward if they suspect an ethical or legal violation has occurred.
- In the United States, several protections are in place for whistle-blowers, such as the Whistleblower Protection Act for government workers and the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act for employees in the securities industry.
- disclosure: The act of revealing something.
A whistle-blower tells the public and/or the authorities about alleged misconduct occurring in a government department, private company, or organization. The alleged misconduct may take a variety of forms; for example, a violation of a law, rule, or regulation, or a direct threat to public interest, such as fraud, health and safety violations, or corruption. Whistle-blowers may make their allegations internally (to other people within the affected organization) or externally (to regulators, law-enforcement agencies, the media, or groups concerned with the issues).
Many organizations establish internal processes through which employees can come forward if they suspect an ethical or legal violation has occurred. In some cases the processes allow for anonymity. Some organizations have an ombudsperson who handles such matters on a confidential basis and advises the employee about their options should they wish to take formal steps to report the breach to the appropriate internal or external authorities.
Legal Protections for Whistle-Blowers in the United States
In the United States several protections are in place for whistle-blowers. The Whistleblower Protection Act safeguards government employees from management retaliation. The No Fear Act prohibits federal managers and supervisors from engaging in unlawful discrimination and retaliation. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires that an individual blow the whistle on an employee who they have evidence has violated the law. Securities whistle-blowers are provided expanded incentives and protection by the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. This legislation authorizes the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to reward whistle-blowers (at companies that are required to report to the SEC) who provide information concerning violations of the federal securities laws. The Freedom of Information Act can be used by a whistle-blower to gather evidence that the public’s right to know has been violated.
Managers Role in Ethical Conduct
Managers are responsible for upholding the ethical code and helping others to do so as well.
Outline the role managers must play in implementing internal ethical standards and aligning the organization with external standards
- Managers hold positions of authority that make them accountable for the ethical conduct of those who report to them.
- Managers monitor the behavior of employees in accordance with the organization ‘s expectations of appropriate behavior, and they have a duty to respond quickly and appropriately to minimize the impact of suspected ethical violations.
- Managers may be responsible for creating and/or implementing changes to the ethical codes or guidelines of an organization.
- Managers may also be subject to a particular code of professional ethics, depending on their position and training. Fiduciary duty is an example that applies to some managerial roles.
- compliance: The department of a business that ensures all government regulations are met.
- accountability: The state of being responsible for something.
- fiduciary: One who holds a thing in trust for another; a trustee.
Managers hold positions of authority that make them accountable for the ethical conduct of those who report to them. They fulfill this responsibility by making sure employees are aware of the organization’s ethical code and have the opportunity to ask questions to clarify their understanding. Managers also monitor the behavior of employees in accordance with the organization’s expectations of appropriate behavior. They have a duty to respond quickly and appropriately to minimize the impact of suspected ethical violations. Lastly, managers make themselves available as a resource to counsel and assist employees who face ethical dilemmas or who suspect an ethical breach.
Of course, managers are responsible for upholding ethical standards in their own actions and decisions. In addition to following the organization’s ethical code, managers may be obligated to follow a separate professional code of ethics, depending on their role, responsibilities, and training. Fiduciary duty is an example that applies to some managerial roles. A fiduciary must put the interests of those to whom he is accountable ahead of any interests, and must not profit from his position as a fiduciary unless the principal consents.
Many managers have responsibility for interacting with external stakeholders such as customers, suppliers, government officials, or community representatives. In those encounters, managers may be called on to explain a decision or a planned action in terms of ethical considerations. The stakeholders will be interested to hear how the organization took ethics into account, and in those cases it is the manager’s duty to speak on the company’s behalf.
Additionally, managers may be responsible for creating and/or implementing changes to an organization’s ethical codes or guidelines. These changes may be in response to an internal determination based on the experience of employees; for instance, additional clarification may be needed about what constitutes nepotism or unfair bias in hiring. Alternatively, new regulations, altered public perceptions and concerns, or other external factors may require the organization to make adjustments.
Codes of Conduct
Organizations adopt codes of conduct to guide employees’ actions and decisions.
State the importance of utilizing a code of conduct to outline and maintain ethical business standards within an organization
- Ethical codes are adopted by organizations to assist members in understanding the difference between right and wrong and how to apply it to their decisions.
- A code of business ethics may set out general principles about an organization’s beliefs on matters such as mission, quality, and the environment. It may delineate proper procedures to determine whether a violation of the code of ethics has occurred and, if so, what remedies should be imposed.
- A code of conduct for employees sets out the procedures that should be used in specific ethical situations. It also delineates the procedures required to determine whether a violation of the code of conduct has occurred and, if so, what remedies should be imposed.
- A code of professional practice discusses common issues and difficult decisions that often arise in a profession, and provides a clear account of what behavior is considered ethical, correct, or right in certain circumstances.
- code: Any system of principles, rules or regulations relating to one subject.
- conduct: The manner of guiding or carrying one’s self; personal deportment; mode of action; behavior.
As part of comprehensive compliance and ethics programs, many companies formulate policies pertaining to the ethical conduct of employees. These policies can be simple exhortations in broad, highly generalized language, or they can be more detailed directives containing specific behavioral requirements. Ethical codes are adopted by organizations to assist members in understanding the difference between right and wrong and applying that understanding to their decisions and actions. They are generally meant to identify the company’s expectations of workers and to offer guidance on handling some of the more common ethical problems that might arise in the course of doing business.
There are three types of ethical codes: codes of business ethics, codes of conduct for employees, and codes of professional practice.
Code of Business Ethics
A code of business ethics often focuses on social issues. It may set out general principles about an organization’s beliefs on matters such as mission, quality, privacy, and the environment. It may delineate procedures that should be used to determine whether a violation of the code of ethics has occurred and, if so, what remedies should be pursued. The effectiveness of such codes of ethics depends on the extent to which management supports and enforces them.
Code of Conduct for Employees
A code of conduct for employees sets out the procedures to be used in specific ethical situations, such as conflicts of interest or the acceptance of gifts. It may include specific lists of dos and don’ts, or it may provide questions to ask to help determine the proper course of action. Codes of conduct typically delineate the proper procedures for determining whether a violation has occurred and for reporting suspected violations.
Code of Practice
A code of practice is adopted to regulate a particular profession. It may be styled as a code of professional responsibility that covers common scenarios and decisions and provides a guide to what behavior is considered ethical, correct, or right in certain circumstances.